K&N if it's available. Million mile warranty, and never need to purchase another filter... ever. All you have to do is every few months take it out and clean it, then spray with the recharging oil and reinstall. I've had one on every single vehicle I've ever owned. The HP and MPG gains are smaller than advertised, but still noticeable.
Owner reviews for air filter
In the past week I've replaced the Timing Belt, Tensioner, Water Pump, flushed the coolant and installed a new Mann Air Filter.
Neuspeed wires Bosh plugs K&n
Engine Info: -K&N air filter.
If you get the Mann C 36 188 /1 , it will have the foam.
If you get a Mann filter, it won't have it.
I've been waiting for all the replacement parts to come in to start tackling the Cabby Overhaul... Today I decided to have a look at the air filter... I was sort of shocked... but not entirely considering it had been sitting for a while before the previous owner picked it up a year ago. I was more shocked that the PO didn't swap out the filter. Man... as well as the car runs in its current state... I can only imagine how well she'll run after a much deserved tune up.
Basically...modest if any gains involved with going with a straight drop in.....the only real benefit IMO....is that for the $60 air filter...you never have to buy another one again...that's the main benefit as far as I'm concerned.
One problem that you can have with the K&N over the stock air filter is over-oiling by novice users. If you over-oil it and the extra oil gets onto the mass air flow sensor, you will need to replace the sensor. Supposedly they aren't cheap either. K&N filters can also be a pain to take care of too. When they get dirty, you have to wash them and re-oil them. This adds another time to screw up.
I've used the air filters made by Amsoil in my current Jetta. I wasn't impressed. The air filter left dust particles on the inside of my intake tube so that was taken out soon after it was installed.
Write your review about air filter
Help others - share your experience with this part.