vs
Brake discs Detroit Axle or OEM BMW
Reviews
May 2025: Oil service, new tires, front brake rotors & pads
Vehicle:
BMW
Use either BMWPartsDirect or GetBMWParts website, buy genuine BMW parts and find a good mechanic in your area (maybe even mobile mechanic who would come to you and replace rotors and pads). In LA I paid $180 for the labor to replace front rotors and pads on my X5, for example.
Vehicle:
BMW X5
The brake disc was really cool
Pros: really cool
Vehicle:
BMW
One of those checks will be a minimum thickness on discs and pads. Given you've only done just over 1000 miles in the vehicle since purchase, it would seem to me that the minimum thickness on the discs when the vehicle was sold to you was at or below that required as part of the pre-sale check.
Pros: minimum thickness on discs
Cons: discs below required thickness
Vehicle:
BMW X5
Mileage: 1609 km
i have detroit axle slotted and ventilated, might be drilled idk don’t feel like checking rn lol, brakes nd they’ve been pretty good the past few months i’ve had em
Pros: pretty good brakes
Buying the brake disc wasn\u2018t even the expensive part. Driving it to the point where it fits the wall, that was.
Vehicle:
BMW
I’m seeing some very small cracks on the cross-drilled holes. At what point does this become concerning? These are the front rotors on a new G82 M4 comp after about 6 track days using Pagid R29 Yellow pads which I’ve used before with no issues. My preference is to keep the stock rotors rather than switching to non cross drilled rotors
Pros: no issues with previous pads
Cons: small cracks on rotors
Vehicle:
BMW M4
For example on my 4 series if you took it to a dealership to have the front disks and pads done you are looking at over £900.
Cons: dealerships get very expensive
Vehicle:
BMW
Those BMW CSL drilled rotors suck. They came\nstock on my e85 M & they cause horrible pedal pulsation. I did a very deep dive on this after multiple sets & replacing multiple parts & checking everything 20x.\n\nThe bottom line is, those rotors are very susceptible to unlocking thickness variation or warped rotors secondary to water getting in the holes & corrosion forming around them.
Cons: horrible pedal pulsation, rotors susceptible to warping
Vehicle:
BMW
If that's a factory BMW floating rotor keep a very close eye on that. Have seen more than one of those come apart (crack gets to edge, ring breaks away from hat), locks a wheel and full sends you in that direction towards the barriers.... Good buddy totaled his z4m and did like 6-7k of armco damage when that happened
Pros: close eye on factory rotors
Cons: rotors can break apart
Vehicle:
BMW Z4
Write your review
Help others - share your experience with this part.
Comparisons
Show all
VS
Brake discs Zimmermann or POWER STOP
VS
Brake discs Brembo or Zimmermann
VS
Brake discs Brembo or POWER STOP
VS
Brake discs Zimmermann or Centric
VS
Brake discs Zimmermann or STOPTECH
VS
Brake discs Zimmermann or OEM Volkswagen
VS
Brake discs Zimmermann or EBC
VS
Brake discs Zimmermann or Raybestos
Show all
Voted AGAINST engine oil RAVENOL on the rating page
The brake pads OEM Alfa Romeo got the first review!
The brake caliper OEM BMW got the first review!
The brake pads OEM Infiniti got the first review!
For wiper blades PIAA already 100 reviews.
For battery Energizer already 25 reviews.
In the rating best water pump already 12 brands participate!
In the rating best timing belt already 13 brands participate!
In the rating best head gasket already 3 brands participate!
In the auto rating oil filter for Volkswagen Passat already 5 brands participate!
In the auto rating brake pads for Mazda 5 already 10 brands participate!
In the auto rating tires for Subaru Outback already 50 brands participate!
For cabin filter Fram already 25 reviews.
Voted AGAINST engine oil RED LINE on the rating page
Voted AGAINST engine oil PENNZOIL on the rating page
Which brake discs to choose — Detroit Axle or OEM BMW?
If choosing brake discs across many manufacturers, check the part ranking. If your choice is down to two brands, the PartReview part comparisons help.
We compare brake discs across these categories:
- PR Score.
- Overall ranking.
- Vote balance.
- Average rating.
- Number of reviews.
- Feature ratings.
- Car owners’ choice.
Which brake discs are better — OEM BMW or Detroit Axle?
In March 2026 on PartReview, brake discs Detroit Axle were overall better than OEM BMW.
- Detroit Axle received a PR Score of 85 out of 100, and OEM BMW scored 54 points.
- Detroit Axle ranked 16 in the overall ranking, and OEM BMW ranked 21.
- The average rating is higher for Detroit Axle (4) than for OEM BMW (3.1).
-
Brake discs Detroit Axle have better feature ratings than OEM BMW:
- Noise - owners believe, that this property for Detroit Axle is better than OEM BMW.
- Braking - drivers claim, that this property for Detroit Axle is outperforms OEM BMW.
- Vibration - reviews suggest, that this property for OEM BMW is preferred to Detroit Axle.
Which brake discs are more popular — Detroit Axle or OEM BMW?
Brake discs Detroit Axle and OEM BMW were equally popular according to data in March 2026.
By vote balance, brake discs Detroit Axle surpassed OEM BMW:
- For Detroit Axle, the ratio of positive (29) to negative (5) votes is 24 votes.
- For OEM BMW, the ratio of positive (37) to negative (31) votes is 6 votes.
By number of reviews, brake discs OEM BMW surpassed Detroit Axle:
- For brake discs Detroit Axle there are 11 reviews: 9 positive, 1 neutral, 1 negative.
- For brake discs OEM BMW there are 21 review: 9 positive, 5 neutral, 7 negative.
Which brake discs do car owners prefer — Detroit Axle or OEM BMW?
In March 2026, according to PartReview, brake discs Detroit Axle and OEM BMW have not taken top places in car-specific ratings. You can help by adding your review about these manufacturers.
Other comparisons of brake discs
If this comparison didn’t fully answer your question, there are many others on PartReview.
For example, comparisons of brake discs Detroit Axle with: Zimmermann, POWER STOP, Brembo, Centric, STOPTECH, OEM Volkswagen, EBC, Raybestos, R1 Concepts, ATE.
Also available: comparisons of brake discs OEM BMW with: Zimmermann, POWER STOP, Brembo, Centric, STOPTECH, OEM Volkswagen, EBC, Raybestos, R1 Concepts, ATE.
You can also see who is better among other brake discs manufacturers: Zimmermann or POWER STOP, Brembo or Zimmermann, Brembo or POWER STOP, Zimmermann or Centric, Zimmermann or STOPTECH.